Ten Reasons Log Data is Not Enough: #3. What’s the Configuration, Kenneth?
September 10, 2009
As we resume our series on why Log Data is Not Enough, the 3rd reason we have underscores the importance of configuration data as part of the security analysis. As we’ve repeatedly mentioned, log management systems are driven by log data. And as we showed in Reason #1, logging can (and usually is) turned off – by savvy attackers anyway.
So how do you detect an attack, if you have no log data to analyze? Basically you need other data sources to figure out what’s happening and that is where configuration data comes in. Every device (whether it’s a firewall, switch, Windows Server, Linux Server, desktops, etc.) has a configuration and you can poll that configuration (with proper authorization) to figure out what’s going on.
Note you have to PULL the config data out of the device. It’s not going to just send it to you (like with log data), so this is actually a big deal to have in a security management platform. It’s a totally different way to gather data and is very hard to do in a scalable fashion with the reliability enterprises demand.
Once you have the configuration baseline, then you can compare new versions of the config to the baseline at a user defined interval. If something changes (like logging is turned off, a new service is turned on, or a registry change happens, for example), it will create an event in the system that can then be used with other data types to determine if it’s really an attack.
Remember systems relying just on log data can’t do this level of analysis. And those vendors that say they do require customers to buy a totally different product with a totally different management interface. Many of these other folks ONLY track network device configuration as well.
So this is another reason that Log Data is Not Enough, and those folks that know they need to go beyond compliance know they need to go beyond log management.
September 17, 2009 at 9:04 AM
[...] 17, 2009 As we discussed in the last post in the Ten Reasons Log Data is Not Enough series, configuration data provides an important additional set of information to help pinpoint [...]
September 21, 2009 at 10:55 AM
[...] key is to be able to ENFORCE POLICY. As we discussed in Reason #3 about configuration data, the key to reacting faster to emerging threats is to detect something different, anomalous, and [...]